Better Data Center Project traces the electricity behind Anthropic’s contracted U.S. compute expansion. Its case study combines dedicated power plants with a model of which grid generators would supply additional demand. The resulting 2028 forecast is overwhelmingly fossil-powered.

  • Projected supply: about 87% gas and 11% coal, counting on-site generation and the grid’s modeled response to new load.
  • Emissions scenario: 17–38 million metric tons of CO2-equivalent annually, with a middle estimate of 32 million.
  • Key assumptions: the middle case puts all 9.6 GW of identified compute capacity online in 2028, at 70% utilization, with facility electricity use 15% above IT equipment use.

Caveat: these are conditional projections of extra generation caused by new demand, not measured consumption or the grids’ average fuel mix. The model assigns no grid renewables to the added load without commitments to new renewable capacity.

That distinction makes the analysis worth reading. A region’s existing clean electricity and a company’s annual energy accounting do not, by themselves, tell us what powers a large new load.

The discussion on Hacker News adds an operational question, competing policy proposals and concrete examples of regulation and heat reuse.

What the thread adds

  • xorcist — asks whether large data centers have actually shifted work to follow cheap, available power. The case study leaves that operational alternative unanswered.
  • dv_dt — proposes requiring new data centers to add 110% renewable capacity.
  • brainwad — argues for pricing emissions instead, so cuts occur where they cost least. These are competing policy proposals.
  • operaopera — points to Spain’s requirement to supply “80% of their hourly energy needs from renewables”. Euronews reports that the approved rules require hourly matching and new renewable capacity. That ties the requirement to when electricity is consumed, beyond annual energy accounting.
  • shakadak — offers a heat-reuse example: “Infomaniak does this with Euria in Geneva, Switzerland.” Infomaniak says its data center feeds recovered heat into Geneva’s district heating network. This is the operator’s account of reuse, separate from the question of which generators supply the electricity.

HN handles are pseudonymous and no per-comment scores are public; HN’s ranking determines the sampled order. This is a slice of the thread, not a consensus.