Peter Yang compares Gemini 4 Neon, Claude Opus 5.5 and Gemini Carbon across five familiar tasks in this 18-minute walkthrough.
Which Gemini model he would use
- Yang picks Neon for most coding, writing and automation, reserving Carbon for unusually demanding projects and Hydrogen for quick questions.
- That is his working preference. The demonstrations below show specific outputs and trade-offs.
1. Shibuya Crossing 3D video
- Neon and Opus each took about 40 minutes in his runs; Carbon took 73 minutes.
- Yang prefers Opus’s dramatic zoom, train and busier crossing, despite visibly artificial people.
- Neon’s reflections look good, but its crossing feels small and some walkers have static legs.
- Carbon’s scene has less convincing street geometry and fewer of the details he wanted.
2. Godzilla game
- Neon runs smoothly, with simple graphics and a breath effect that appears to emerge from the creature’s neck.
- Opus adds a more atmospheric introduction, richer destruction and more effects, but plays noticeably slower on Yang’s MacBook M5.
- Carbon’s camera behavior prevents him from properly seeing the character move.
- Yang gives Opus the visual win while acknowledging Neon’s better responsiveness.
3. Website redesign
- Neon produces a clearer landing page than Carbon, with a call to action and an animated visual.
- Carbon overloads the page with text and decorative elements.
- Yang still prefers Opus’s bolder motion design, clothes-hanger interface and drawers.
4. Writing and revision
- All three write a fictional software engineer’s reflection on no longer typing code manually.
- Yang narrowly ranks the essays Neon, Carbon, then Opus, while calling the results close and taste-dependent.
- The reveal is only partly blind: he admits recognizing Carbon’s essay from an earlier video.
- Neon also gives concise revision bullets and before-and-after examples; Carbon’s feedback is harder for him to scan.
5. Advice under pushback
- Neon recommends a separate interview channel; Carbon proposes dropping interviews; Opus recommends timely solo tests plus selective guests.
- Yang prefers Opus’s advice, while acknowledging that he personally enjoys making interviews.
- He reports pushing back five ways and finding broadly similar resistance across models, with real data prompting revisions.
- The walkthrough shows selected exchanges, so it supports a small qualitative comparison rather than a measured resistance score.
Keep the workflow portable
- Yang’s broader recommendation is to retain skills and workflows in a personal repository that works across models and agent software.
- His conclusion is narrower than a universal ranking: Neon feels competitive for everyday writing and advice; Opus remains his visual-design favorite.
- Caveat: these are creator-presented examples and personal judgments, with no independently reproduced benchmark or repeated-run statistics.
“The most durable thing that you can build is your own personal system of AI skills and workflows.” — Peter Yang, 16:31