Nicolas Bouliane has run All About Berlin since 2017 and lived from it since 2020. In this May essay, he attributes a 75% traffic loss to Google’s AI Overviews. His current page revises an earlier 70% figure.
- Searchers can receive an AI answer assembled from publishers’ work before reaching the source links.
- Bouliane says he now spends time preparing another livelihood instead of writing new guides.
- He reports that other owners have paywalled their work or left websites online while stopping updates.
The cost extends beyond lost visits. Answers detached from his guides also remove his wording, recognition and relationships with readers. Information can remain searchable long after its maintenance stops paying.
Caveat: this is the publisher’s account and traffic chart; it cannot isolate AI Overviews from other changes in search.
The 516-comment thread on Hacker News adds a current update and competing views of how readers should get their answers.
What the thread adds
- nicbou, identifying himself as Nicolas, says: “Things got worse, but so far, I can still live from the website.” He says next year might be his last running it full time. The business has not already closed.
- rcymerys says they now visit directly because Google/ChatGPT results led them astray. They also acknowledge that this habit depends on already knowing the site.
- mertbio describes building a Hamburg guide as an app, accepting harder discovery in exchange for more control. That is an attempted alternative, not a demonstrated solution.
- helsinkiandrew argues that readers may prefer a synthesized answer to navigating uncertain-quality pages with affiliate incentives. In reply to a similar argument, nicbou says: “Summaries often lose advice that you did not ask for, but still need to receive.”
- nicbou disputes the idea that the site merely repackages existing information: “Many of the things on the website come from interviews with experts, or from collecting data directly.” His linked immigration-office wait-time tracker solicits application updates from readers. Maintaining that source requires more than summarizing other pages.
Handles are pseudonymous; HN publishes no per-comment scores, and ordering is HN’s ranking. This is a slice of the thread, not a consensus.